Maize Genetics Cooperation Newsletter vol 84 2010
Please Note: Notes submitted to the
Maize Genetics Cooperation Newsletter may be cited only with consent of
authors.
Maize and Sorghum Research
Institute
Pascani, Republic of Moldova
Frequency of reversion of o2-m(r) alleles as a characteristic
of specificity of their interaction with regulatory Bg elements 1
--V. V. Koterniak 2
1 This note is a shortened version of a full size article which had been
submitted for publication, however, due to termination of my work in Maize and Sorghum Research Institute its publication
has not been finalized. However I would like to share main result and
conclusions of this article with the maize community.
2 Present address: Pharmasciance Inc., Montreal, Canada
Reversions
of mutable o2-m(r) alleles
occur mostly postmeiotically during gametophyte development or later during
endosperm development (Montanelli et al., Mol. Gen. Genet. 197: 209-218, 1984; Koterniak; MNL 76: 54; Genetika (Moscow) 39:769-774) and rarely at late stages before meiosis
(MNL 76: 54; Genetika (Moscow) 39: 709-712,
2003). Phenotypic expression of o2-m(r) alleles reversion depends on its timing. The
earlier it occurs during endosperm development the higher is the portion of the
vitreous tissue in variegated endosperm. Reversion occurring before the first
mitotic division of the primary endosperm nucleus determines appearance of
phenotypically normal kernels or whole endosperm revertants (WER) (Salamini, Molecular
and General Genetics 179: 497-507, 1980; Montanelli et al., Molecular and
General Genetics 197: 209-218, 1984).
Earlier,
the specificity in interaction between regulatory elements Bg-hf and Bg-lf in relation to reversion frequency of o2-hf and o2-lf alleles has been established. Thus, in two or three doses the Bg-lf element determined low reversion frequency of
the o2-lf allele but high
reversion frequency of the o2-hf allele, whereas the presence in the same doses of Bg-hf determined high reversion frequency of both
the o2-hf and o2-lf alleles (Maydica 48: 275-281, 2003).
Rather
unexpected therefore was finding of very high reversion frequency of the o2-hf allele in presence of standard Bg-Ref element (this paper). Percentage of
phenotypically normal kernels on homozygous o2-hf, Bg-Ref ears was higher than that of the o2-hf, Bg-hf ears obtained under selection for high WER content and often did not
differ significantly from the content of normal kernels observed in
heterozygous O2 ears.
To
reveal plants carrying the wild-type O2 allele (i. e. descendants of embryo revertant kernels) selfing and
crossing with the o2-R, +Bg (rarely with the o2-m(r), +Bg) testers (i.e. with testers containing
recessive o2 alleles and
lacking regulatory Bg
elements) were made. In contrast to the crosses in which o2-hf, Bg-Ref strains were used as male parent (contained one
dose of regulatory element), in reciprocal crosses and selfed ears (containing
respectively two and three doses of Bg-Ref) high WER content can significantly change kernel phenotype ratio
impeding determination of embryo revertants in this material. Therefore in the
analysis of kernel segregation ratios of the latter crosses the ratios
characteristic for heterozygous O2 ears, were considered as uncertain, if the testcrosses in which the
same plants were used as male parent were not available.
The
data on frequency of reversion of o2-hf and o2-lf alleles
in presence of Bg-Ref and the earlier published data (Maydica 48:
275-281, 2003) on frequency of reversion of these alleles in presence of the Bg-hf and Bg-lf were obtained in the same experiment carried out in 2002. Determination
of embryo revertants was carried out in the progeny of all WER and a part of
variegated kernels of two ears of the o2-hf/o2-R, Bg-Ref/+Bg genotype (ears 02-4574�4742p152 and 02-4573�4742p131) and in the
progeny of all kernels of one homozygous o2-hf, Bg-Ref ear (ear 02-4568p131, 253 WER and 168
variegated, i.e. 60.10% of WER).
Evaluation
of significance of differences between observed and expected frequencies was
carried out by the χ2 test.
High WER content is characteristic for
the o2-hf, Bg-Ref but not for o2-lf, Bg-Ref genotypes
Lower
reversion frequency of the o2-lf allele in comparison to the o2-hf allele in presence of
standard Bg-Ref element
have been determined on the first and second generation of the crosses of o2-hf, +Bg and o2-lf, +Bg
strains with the o2-R, Bg-Ref line (Maydica 44: 195-203, 1999). However values
of reversion frequency of the o2-hf allele in presence of Bg-Ref which were higher than the reversion frequency of the same allele in
presence of the Bg-hf element
(i. e. the regulatory element obtained under selection for high WER content) were
quite unexpected.
The
major part (68%) of homozygous o2-hf, Bg-Ref ears contained more than 50% of phenotypically
wild-type kernels (Table 1). The ratio of phenotypically normal to variegated
kernels in o2-hf, Bg-Ref
genotypes often did not deviate significantly from the ratios of such kernels
observed on ears heterozygous for normal O2 allele. Thus on about half of selfed ears this
ratio was statistically indistinguishable from 3:1 or higher (Table 1). Most
variegated kernels on selfed o2-hf, Bg-Ref ears were characterized by small and very small opaque sectors
surrounded by vitreous tissue (Figure 1).
In
contrast to the o2-hf, Bg-Ref strains the described phenomenon of high WER
content in o2-lf, Bg-Ref genotypes was not observed (Table 1, Figure
2). Among selfed o2-lf, Bg-Ref ears none had the excess of WER kernels over
variegated ones (Table 1). Revertant content in o2-lf, Bg-Ref genotypes observed at three Bg-Ref doses was statistically higher than the same
parameter observed with two doses of Bg-Ref (Table 1).
Most kernels on the ears with high WER
content are not embryo revertants
Out
of 67 tested progenies of one of the two studied ears of the o2-hf/o2-R,
Bg-Ref/+Bg genotype (ear 02-4574�4742p152) three were heterozygous O2 plants. No heterozygous O2 plants were found in 59 progenies of the
second o2-hf/o2-R, Bg-Ref/+Bg ear. In the progeny of selfed homozygous o2-hf, Bg-Ref
ear (02-4568p131) 18 plants can be considered as embryo revertants (Table 2).
Two
heterozygous O2 plants, descendent
of o2-hf/o2-R, Bg-Ref/+Bg ear and 12 of homozygous o2-hf, Bg-Ref
ear were found in progenies of 37 and 108 WER kernels, respectively, giving
frequency of their formation in progeny of WER kernels equal to 5.41 (2/37�100) and 5.56%
(12/(2�108)�100)) respectively. Two plants homozygous for the wild-type O2 allele (originated from WER kernels) were
found in the progeny of selfed o2-hf, Bg-Ref ear (Table 2).
It
is necessary to mention that presence of variegated kernels in two out of three
embryo revertant ears (i.e. in ears heterozygous for wild-type O2 allele and non-mutable o2-R allele) found in the progeny of the o2-hf/o2-R,
Bg-Ref/+Bg ear (Table 2А) is unexpected and needs
to be explained (see below).
At
3 out of 16 plants (03-4225p4, 03-4411p4,
03-4432p4 in Table 2B) considered as O2 heterozygotes (i.e. carrying wild-type O2 and o2-hf alleles) in the progeny of selfed o2-hf, Bg-Ref ear, the content of variegated kernels in
crosses with the o2-R, +Bg, tester (used as
female parent), was significantly higher than expected. This excess of
variegated kernels is apparently conditioned by the same causes as the
described above phenomenon of apparition of variegated kernels on heterozygous O2/o2-R,
Bg-Ref/+Bg ears (see below). It is necessary to mention
that the content of phenotypically wild-type kernels at these three ears
(24.06-42.78%) is much higher than at homozygous o2-hf, Bg-Ref strains (maximum WER content on their ears was equal to 8.07%, Table
3B). Significant deviations from expected ratios due to excess of normal
kernels which are mostly observed in the crosses of the o2-hf, Bg-Ref strains with the o2-R, +Bg tester used as male
parent and on selfed ears (Table 2B) are conditioned by high frequency of WER
formation especially in presence of two or three doses of regulatory Bg-Ref element (see below).
Revealed
embryo revertants did not belong to the same pairs of spikelets, however five
embryo revertants on homozygous o2-hf, Bg-Ref ear (Table 2) were in two clusters consisting from two and three contiguous
kernels presented in adjacent pairs of spikelets (data not shown).
High WER content in o2-hf, Bg-Ref genotypes needs the presence
of two or three doses of the regulatory element
Comparison
of WER content on selfed homozygous o2-hf, Bg-Ref ears and in their reciprocal crosses with the o2-R, +Bg showed that high WER content needs the
presence of two or three doses of Bg-Ref. Thus with one dose of this regulatory
element, WER percentage (about 2%) is approximately 24 times lower than with
three doses of Bg-Ref (Table 3).
With
three Bg-Ref doses percentage of phenotypically normal
kernels is higher than with its two doses, however the value calculated per one
Bg-Ref dose (or as the reversion frequency of o2-hf ) was higher at two doses of Bg-Ref, differences in both cases being insignificant
(Table 3).
Possible causes of high frequency of
reversion of o2-hf
in presence of Bg-Ref
Several
causes could be connected with high content of phenotypically wild-type kernels
in o2-hf, Bg-Ref genotypes:
(i) action of modifiers; (ii) earlier (i. e. before meiosis) developmental
stage of o2-hf reversion in
presence of Bg-Ref; (iii)
specific interaction between o2-hf allele and Bg-Ref
element.
An
assumption about action of modifiers is unlikely since sharply different on
revertant content genotypes o2-hf, Bg-Ref and o2-lf, Bg-Ref have been obtained in the crosses of the same o2-R, Bg-Ref line with
closely related strains o2-hf,
+Bg and o2-lf, +Bg
and differences in reversion frequencies of responsive alleles of these strains
were not caused by modifiers unlinked to the o2 locus (Maydica 44: 195-203, 1999; MNL 73:
76-79, 1999).
Regulatory element Bg-Ref does not condition earlier reversion
of the o2-hf allele
in development
Obtained
data showed, that frequency of formation of embryo revertants from WER kernels
in studied o2-hf, Bg-Ref ears (5.41 and 5.56%) is approximately on the
same level with this trait of the o2-hf,
Bg-hf strains (1.82-8.18%) (Genetika (Moscow) 39: 709-712; 2003)
indicating that reversion of the o2-hf allele in presence of Bg-Ref element (as well as in that of the Bg-hf) occurs mostly at the period from
fertilization to the first division of the primary endosperm nucleus. The size
of embryo revertant clusters formed from the kernels (of two and three kernels)
was also equal to that of observed in homozygous o2-hf, Bg-hf genotypes (Genetika (Moscow) 39:
709-712; 2003). Proceeding from the frequency of formation of
heterozygous O2 ears in the
progeny of WER kernels obtained from analyzed selfed homozygous o2-hf, Bg-Ref
ear (the ear 02-4568p131) and the number of WER kernels on this ear (5.56% and
253, respectively) the apparition of two plants homozygous for wild-type O2 allele found in the progeny of mentioned ear
and the apparition of two kernel embryo revertant cluster, as a result of o2-hf reversion in gametes at postmeiotic stages of
development is not excluded. However frequency of formation of three kernels
embryo revertant cluster (1.7×10-4 or 0.05563) on
selfed o2-hf, Bg-Ref ear indicates that premeiotic reversion of o2-hf is more probable. Small size of this cluster
indicates on both the late stages of premeiotic development at which the
reversion of o2-hf can
rarely occur and confirms that the early reversion of this allele is not the
main cause of high WER content in o2-hf, Bg-Ref genotypes.
Kernel segregation ratios of on certain
heterozygous O2 ears
and phenotype of o2-hf,
Bg-Ref kernels indicate on
possibility of intragenic transposition of rbg element in the o2 gene
The
o2-hf, Bg-Ref genotypes,
besides having high content of phenotypically normal kernels, also have another
characteristic feature: their variegated kernels appear as small and very small
opaque sectors in vitreous background (Figure 1). Taking into account small
size of opaque sectors and their encirclement by vitreous tissue it is possible
to conclude that these sectors originate at the late stages of endosperm
development as a result of insertion of Bg
or rbg elements in wild-type O2 allele leading to inactivation of this allele
and therefore to opaque tissue. Similar mechanism, based on intragenic
transposition of nonautonomous Ds
element has been proposed for the wx1 endosperm variegation observed for the Wx1-m5 allele (Weil et al., Genetics 130: 175-185, 1992).
Since
apparition of wild-type O2
allele at the o2-hf,
Bg-Ref genotypes is
conditioned by excision of the rbg element from the o2-hf allele and if the above described phenotype of o2-hf, Bg-Ref kernels is originated from the rbg
insertion in the o2 locus
it is possible to refer to such insertion as to the reinsertion of rbg. In case if rbg reinsertions does not lead to exact
restoration of the sequence existing before excision of this element (though
direct data for rbg is not
available, transposons excision are often imprecise and rarely show strong
target site preference (see for example reviews of Saedler and Nevers, EMBO J.
4: 585-590,1985; Wessler, Science 242: 399-405, 1988; Walker et al., Genetics
146: 681-693 1997; Kunze and Weil,
In: Mobile DNA II. P. 565-610. Edited by N. L. Craig et al. ASM Press,
Washington, D.C. P, 2002), these
reinsertions are in fact intragenic transpositions of rbg. Earlier (Genetika
(Moscow) 39:769-774, 2003a) proceeding from similarity in behavior
between o2-hf allele with class 2 mutable an3 petunia alleles (these alleles, which are
under control of the dTph1 transposon of the hAT superfamily, have been
described by van Houwelingen et al (The Plant Cell. 11: 1319–1336, 1999)
an assumption was made that in case of o2-hf allele in or near the o2 locus two receptor rbg elements may be present. In such a case it is possible to
expect that presence of two rbg
elements increases the probability of their intragenic transpositions. It is
interesting to mention that in case of the Wx-m5 allele, a part of new alleles arisen due to
intragenic transposition of Ds carries two Ds
elements in the wx1 gene (Weil
et al., Genetics 130:
175-185, 1992).
Proposed
mechanism of Bg or rbg insertion in the wild-type O2 allele explains not only above described
phenotype of o2-hf, Bg-Ref
kernels but also explains both the apparition of variegated kernels in two out
of three embryo revertant O2/o2-R, Bg-Ref/+Bg
ears and higher than expected portion of variegated kernels in 3 out of 16
heterozygous O2/o2-hf, Bg-Ref/+Bg ears in progeny of selfed o2-hf, Bg-Ref ear (Table 2).
Dosage effects of studied Bg regulatory elements and some
inferences about mechanism of action of Bg transposase
Data
presented in Table 3B indicate that with two times regulatory element Bg-Ref dose increase (from one to two), reversion
frequency of the o2-hf
allele increases approximately by 6 times (Table 3B). Considering excision of
the rbg element as a
biochemical reaction (e.g. Zhang and Peterson, Genetics 153: 1403-1410, 1999)
much higher increase of reversion frequency indicates that the order of this
reaction is higher than one and that the rbg
excision occurs as a result of action of Bg
transposase oligomers consisting of several transposase molecules participating
in forming of transposition complexes. The same conclusion was made comparing
reversion frequency of the o2-hf allele under the dose increase of the Bg regulatory elements from 1 to 2 (Maydica 48: 275-281, 2003).
Though
little is known about eukaryotic transposition complexes (transpososomes),
participation of several proteins and protein-protein interaction are suggested
in their formation (reviewed in Essers et al., The Plant Cell 12:
211–223, 2000).
Formation of transposase oligomers has shown to be necessary for activity of
the Ac encoded transposase
(Kunze et al., Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 90: 7094-7098; Essers et al., The
Plant Cell 12: 211–223, 2000). It is important to note that the C terminus of Ac transposase responsible for dimerization is
the most conservative transposase region of the hAT superfamily of transposons (Essers et al., The
Plant Cell 12: 211–223, 2000). On the basis of sequence similarity, to this superfamily both the
Ac and Bg elements belong that suggests similarity in
their transposition mechanisms (Harting et al., Molecular and General Genetics
227: 91-96, 1991; Kunze et
al., Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 90: 7094-7098; Atkinson et al., Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 90: 9693-9697, 1993).
In
this context, insignificant differences in frequency of reversion of o2-hf observed under regulatory elements dose
increase from 2 to 3 (Table 3; Genetika
(Moscow) 39: 769-774, 2003; Maydica
48: 275-281, 2003) can be explained
by aggregation of mentioned transposase oligomers leading to their
inactivation. Analogous mechanism of aggregation of the Ac encoded transposase oligomers has been
proposed as one of possible mechanisms of the Ds excision inhibition at high transposase
concentrations (Scofield et al., The Plant Cell. 4: 573-582, 1992; Kunze et
al., Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 90: 7094-7098; 1993; Heinlein et al., 1994;
Heinlein, Plant J. 5: 705–714, 1996; Essers et al., The Plant Cell 12:
211–223, 2000).
Origin of o2-hf and o2-lf alleles and their behavior in presence of regulatory Bg elements can be explained by
participation of the rbg
element product in rbg
excision from these alleles
In
contrast to the o2-hf
allele, reversion frequency of the o2-lf allele increases under dose increase of all studied regulatory elements
from 2 to 3 (Table 1, Figure 2; Genetika
(Moscow) 39: 769-774, 2003; Maydica
48: 275-281, 2003). This regularity is observed at
different levels of reversion frequency: at low frequency of reversion of the o2-lf in presence with Bg-lf element (Genetika (Moscow) 39: 769-774, 2003; Maydica 48: 275-281, 2003); at medium frequency with Bg-Ref (Table 1) and at high level in combination
with Bg-hf (Maydica 48:
275-281, 2003).
Different
behavior of o2-hf and o2-lf alleles under regulatory elements dose
increase from 2 to 3 can be explained assuming interaction of Bg transposase oligomers with
differing products of the rbg
elements inserted in these alleles, the interaction resulting in changed
properties of transpososomes. The possibility of such interaction is indicated
by sequence similarity between the Bg
and rbg elements: rbg differs from Bg by small deletion and insertion
events and the two elements share more than 75% homology based on sequence data
(Hartings et al., Molecular and General Genetics 227: 91-96, 1991). If the
product of the rbg element
inserted in o2-lf allele in
its interaction with Bg
transposase oligomers determine higher level of inactivation of transposase
oligomers than the level of inactivation of the oligomers containing the
product the rbg element
present in the o2-hf
allele, this can explaine different behavior of studied alleles with the
regulatory elements dose increase from 2 to 3.
For
other transposable element systems there are data indicating on rather
complicated character of interaction between autonomous and non-autonomous
elements. Thus, Kunze et al. ( Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 90: 7094-7098, 1993)
have established that some transpositionally inactive transposase plasmids lead
to an increase of Ds excision
frequency when they are co-expressed with the active truncated transposase. In
work of Cuypers et al. (EMBO J. 7: 2953-2960, 1988) a product of the defective En-I102 element was suggested to be responsible (acting as competitive
inhibitor) for the reduced ability of the autonomous En element to induce excisions of the receptor
element. Interestingly, for the En/Spm system of maize transposons it was shown that interaction between two
proteins TnpA and TnpD is essential for forming transposition complexes (Raina
et al., Proc. Natl. Acad.
Sci. USA 95: 8526-8531, 1998). These proteins sharing significant degree of
homology originate from a single Spm transcript by alternative splicing (Masson et al., Cell 58: 755-765, 1989)
Accepting
above presented hypothesis it is possible to conclude that apparition of the
sharply different o2-hf and
o2-lf alleles as a result
of change in state of the initial o2-m(r):3449 allele under disruptive selection for WER content
(Maydica 44: 195-203, 1999) is conditioned by changes in the rbg elements affecting in opposite directions the
ability of rbg products for
interaction with transposition complexes responsible for rbg excision. Accordingly, changes in the initial Bg-3449 element, which conditioned apparition of Bg-hf and Bg-lf elements under the same disruptive selection (Maydica 44: 195-203,
1999), could lead to the changes in their encoded transposases that affected
affinity of these transposases toward rbg element products.
Another
indication of effect of selection on Bg-hf elements (and hence on its encoded transposase) can be the higher
frequency of reversion of o2-hf in presence of the Bg-Ref element than in presence of Bg-hf. The changes in the Bg-hf conditioning certain upper level of the rbg excisions could be determined by used method
of disruptive selection for high WER content (in which the Bg-hf element was obtained): the ears containing
significantly more than 50% of WER were not selected for next cycle of selection
(Maydica 44: 195-203, 1999) since in this case it were more difficult to
distinguish the ears with high WER content from the ears heterozygous for
normal O2 allele.
Table 1 -
Distribution of ears obtained on homozygous o2-hf, Bg-Ref and o2-lf, Bg-Ref plants and in their crosses
with o2-R, +Bg tester (male parent)
based on the ratio of phenotypically normal (n) to variegated (v) kernels
Plant genotype |
Number of ears |
% WER� |
RF, %� |
||||
total studi-ed |
with the n/v ratio |
||||||
=1� |
>1 |
=3� |
>3 |
||||
Selfed plants |
|||||||
o2-hf, Bg-Ref |
38 |
12 |
26 |
5 |
13 |
47.91a�� |
15.97a |
o2-lf, Bg-Ref |
13 |
1 |
0 |
0 |
0 |
17.24b |
5.75b |
Crosses with o2-R, +Bg
used as male parent |
|||||||
o2-hf, Bg-Ref |
30 |
4 |
6 |
2 |
1 |
26.08c |
13.04c |
o2-lf, Bg-Ref |
19 |
1 |
1 |
0 |
0 |
4.31d |
2.16d |
�
Significant by χ2 test.
��
A common letter at the means indicates on insignificance of differences
(P=0.05).
�
Here and in Table 3, reversion frequency (RF), calculated as WER percentage per
one dose of responsive allele.
�
Calculated without considering ears with the ratio of WER to variegated kernels
characteristic for heterozygous O2 plants.
Table 2 - Kernel segregation
in embryo revertants found in progeny of two ears of o2-hf/o2-R, Bg-Ref/+Bg and homozygous o2-hf, Bg-Ref genotypes
Plant number |
Crossing with o2-R, +Bg or
with o2-m(r), +Bg (b) used as female parent |
Selfing (a)
or crossing with o2-R, +Bg or with o2-m(r), +Bg (b) used as male parent |
|||||||
Number of kernels |
χ21:1 c |
Number of kernels |
χ21:1 |
χ23:1 |
|||||
nd |
v |
o |
n |
v |
o |
||||
1 |
2 |
3 |
4 |
5 |
6 |
7 |
8 |
9 |
10 |
A. Progeny of the ear 02-4574�4742p152 of o2-hf/o2-R, Bg-Ref/+Bg genotype |
|||||||||
03-4210p1e |
- |
- |
- |
- |
148 |
0 |
148 |
0.00 |
- |
03-4210p13 |
- |
- |
- |
- |
166 |
8 |
175 |
0.00 |
- |
03-4446p7 |
- |
- |
- |
- |
84 |
33 |
118 |
0.00 |
- |
B. Progeny of the ear 02-4568p131 of homozygous o2-hf, Bg-Ref genotype |
|||||||||
03-4211p19 |
74 |
59 |
0 |
1.69 |
197 |
83 |
0 |
46.41*** |
- |
03-4212p7f |
26 |
12 |
0 |
5.16* |
220b |
77b |
0b |
68.85*** |
- |
03-4212p19 |
78 |
61 |
0 |
2.08 |
210 |
50 |
0 |
98.46*** |
- |
03-4219p3 |
88 |
75 |
0 |
1.04 |
174 |
70 |
0 |
44.33*** |
- |
03-4225p4e |
70 |
221 |
0 |
78.35*** |
147 |
40 |
0 |
61.22*** |
- |
03-4226p16 |
71 |
0 |
0 |
- |
158 |
0 |
0 |
- |
- |
03-4404p13g |
97 |
97 |
0 |
0.00 |
147 |
67 |
0 |
29.91*** |
- |
03-4404p16g |
28 |
20 |
0 |
1.33 |
177 |
104 |
0 |
18.96*** |
- |
Table 2 (continued)
1 |
2 |
3 |
4 |
5 |
6 |
7 |
8 |
9 |
10 |
03-4406p7e |
66 |
62 |
0 |
0.13 |
122 |
45 |
0 |
35.50*** |
- |
03-4411p4 |
80 |
107 |
0 |
3.90* |
171 |
69 |
0 |
43.35*** |
- |
03-4415p19 |
103 |
109 |
0 |
0.17 |
326a |
39a |
0a |
- |
39.89*** |
03-4418p13 |
28 |
41 |
0 |
2.45 |
171 |
95 |
0 |
21.71*** |
- |
03-4420p4e |
82 |
23 |
0 |
33.15*** |
219 |
181 |
0 |
3.61 |
- |
03-4421p16 |
- |
- |
- |
- |
310 |
0 |
0 |
- |
- |
03-4428p3 |
70 |
76 |
0 |
0.25 |
112 |
59 |
0 |
16.43*** |
- |
03-4432p3ef |
128b |
153b |
0b |
2.22 |
228a |
32a |
0a |
- |
22.33*** |
03-4432p4f |
65 |
120 |
0 |
16.35*** |
137a |
35a |
0a |
- |
1.98 |
03-4433p13 |
59 |
50 |
0 |
0.74 |
117 |
67 |
0 |
12.78*** |
- |
c For progenies of the ear 02-4574x4742p152 (part A of the table) the 1:1
ratio was the ratio of the sum of normal and variegated kernels to opaque ones;
for the progenies of the ear 02-4568p131 (part B of the table) the ratios 1:1
and 3:1 were the ratios of phenotypically normal kernels to variegated.
d Here and in Table 3, n, v, o indicate
phenotypically normal (normal or WER), variegated and opaque kernels
respectively.
e Plant originated from variegated
kernel (not marked are plants from phenotypically normal kernels).
f, g Plants from clusters
of three (f) and two (g) embryo revertants consisting
from contiguous kernels presented in adjacent pairs of spikelets (data not
shown).
*, *** Significance of deviation from expected at
P=0.05 and P=0.001, respectively.
- Indicates not applicable (for the χ2 test) or data
not available
Table 3 - Comparison of whole
endosperm revertants (WER) content in o2-hf, Bg-Ref genotypes observed at one, two
and three doses of regulatory element Bg-Ref
Plant number |
Crossing with o2-R, +Bg used as female parent (1 Bg-Ref dose) |
Selfing (A) or crossing
(B) with the o2-R, +Bg used as male
parent(3 or 2 Bg-Ref doses, respectively) |
|||||||
Number of kernels |
WER, % |
Number of kernels |
WER, % |
RF, % |
|||||
n |
v |
o |
n |
v |
o |
||||
1 |
2 |
3 |
4 |
5 |
6 |
7 |
8 |
9 |
10 |
A. Comparison between 1
and 3 doses of the Bg-Ref |
|||||||||
03-4425p16 |
0 |
12 |
0 |
0 |
141 |
201 |
0 |
41.23 |
13.74 |
03-4427p4 |
1 |
28 |
0 |
3.45 |
68 |
164 |
0 |
29.31 |
9.77 |
03-4432p19 |
2 |
104 |
0 |
1.89 |
78 |
123 |
0 |
38.81 |
12.94 |
03-4433p3 |
3 |
107 |
0 |
2.73 |
179 |
53 |
0 |
77.16 |
25.72 |
03-4433p4 |
4 |
84 |
0 |
4.55 |
108 |
129 |
0 |
45.57 |
15.19 |
03-4433p19 |
2 |
131 |
0 |
1.50 |
180 |
131 |
0 |
57.88 |
19.29 |
03-4435p3 |
1 |
182 |
0 |
0.55 |
140 |
164 |
0 |
46.05 |
15.35 |
Total |
13 |
648 |
0 |
1.97a� |
894 |
965 |
0 |
48.09b |
16.03c |
B. Comparison between 1
and 2doses of the Bg-Ref |
|||||||||
03-4218p7 |
2 |
145 |
0 |
1.38 |
114 |
145 |
0 |
44.02 |
22.01 |
03-4218p19 |
2 |
172 |
0 |
1.16 |
74 |
158 |
0 |
31.90 |
15.95 |
03-4222p4 |
0 |
154 |
0 |
0.00 |
99 |
126 |
1 |
44.00 |
22.00 |
03-4224p7 |
18 |
223 |
0 |
8.07 |
144 |
128 |
0 |
52.94 |
26.47 |
03-4226p10 |
1 |
84 |
0 |
1.19 |
91 |
207 |
0 |
30.54 |
15.27 |
03-4226p19 |
4 |
50 |
0 |
8.00 |
89 |
169 |
0 |
34.50 |
17.25 |
03-4229p19 |
7 |
136 |
0 |
5.15 |
128 |
112 |
0 |
53.33 |
26.67 |
Total� |
34 |
964 |
0 |
3.53a |
739 |
1045 |
1 |
41.42b |
20.71c |
�
A common letter at the means indicates on insignificance of differences
(P=0.05).
�
Only 7 out of 34 studied reciprocal crosses
are presented (analogous data on both samples).
Figure 1
- Kernel phenotypes observed
at o2-m(r) alleles. Upper
row (from left to right): phenotypically wild-type (whole endosperm revertant,
WER) kernel formed as a result of o2-m(r) excision before the first division of primary endosperm nucleus;
variegated kernel (vitreous sectors in opaque background) arisen due to o2-m(r) reversion in presence of a Bg element during endosperm development, commonly
observed at o2-m(r)
alleles; opaque kernel phenotype conditioned by the o2-m(r) allele in absence of the regulatory Bg elements. Two variegated kernels in the lower
row which are characterized by small and very small opaque sectors in vitreous
background are usually observed in o2-hf, Bg-Ref genotypes.